Refund policy

We want you to be completely satisfied with your purchase. If you find that you need to return an item, please review the complete details of our return policy below to determine if any special return conditions apply.

Items may be returned within 30 days of the ship date for a refund. While most items are returnable, they are subject to the following guidelines:

Trading Cards

Trading Cards means any trading card product ie: Pokemon, Magic The Gathering, Lorcana, Yu-Gi-Oh, One Piece and more.

Trading Card Products are Not Returnable once sold and shipped. 

If you have an issue with a trading card product please contact customerservice@fye.com for more information. 

Blind Bags, Mystery items, One random assortment items:

Blind Bags Mystery items and items that are selected at random from an assortment of options are not returnable. You are taking a chance on getting one of various options. These Products are Not Returnable once sold and shipped. 

If you have an issue with one of these products please contact customerservice@fye.com for more information. 

Food & Beverage items

All sales are final on food and beverage items. These Products are Not Returnable once sold and shipped and cannot be returned. 


Defective, Damaged or Misshipped Items

You will receive a refund for the item(s) and shipping and handling costs for defective, damaged or misshipped items. For all other items, shipping and handling costs cannot be refunded. (Note: Return shipping cost refunds are calculated using the lowest cost shipping method. Items returned via expanded shipping methods will only be refunded an amount equal to the lowest cost shipping method).


*Please contact customerservice@fye.com for a RA number and return instructions. Merchandise must be in new condition with its original packing and accessories intact or it may be subject to a restocking fee. A refund will be issued for the price of the item upon its check in and processing. Shipping and Handling fees are not refundable.

Proper Conditions for Return and Credit

Returned merchandise must be in new condition with its original packing and accessories intact or it may be subject to a restocking fee. If you are returning a product listed below, please check to make sure your return meets the conditions described.

  • Music, Movies, Video Games, Electronics, Accessories, and Toys/Collectibles must be unopened.
  • Books must be in their original condition.
  • Clothing must be unworn & unwashed.
  • Perishables and personal care items (including earrings) - May not be returned, unless defective or misshipped.
  • No personalized items may be returned.
We are not able to accept returns on orders for items delivered via Curbside Delivery. If you have ordered one of these products please inspect the item carefully PRIOR TO SIGNING FOR IT. If the item is incorrect or damaged refuse the delivery and you will receive a full refund. Once the item has been accepted it will be assumed to be correct and in good working condition. Any issues that arise after the item is signed for must be resolved through the manufacturers warranty.

To request a Return Authorization Number (RA#) for an item, please contact customerservice@fye.com. Include your name and order number in any correspondence.

Returns will not be accepted without a RA number. Please include the RA number on the outside of the shipping package. (Please do not write directly on the manufacturer's box).

Returning an item(s) may change or void coupon discounts or refunds currently appearing on an order.

For your protection, please send your return prepaid via a shipping service that can be tracked, such as UPS. Please be sure to keep your receipt. We cannot guarantee refunds for returns sent via a non-trackable method.

Credits are processed upon confirmation of the return by our suppliers. Please allow up to two billing cycles for the return credit to appear on your credit card statement. If credit cannot be issued to your credit card, a store credit will be issued.