Rating:
Genre:
Rock
Release Date: 11/04/2003
Five friends who grew up together in Dublin, called
the Thrills, have produced a remarkably neat debut album. At the heart of their sound is a professed love for the tunes of the American West Coast of the '60s and '70s. Set to a backdrop of
Al Green,
Carole King, and
the Band, they quickly pieced together tracks for their debut album,
So Much for the City, during a four-month holiday on a beach in San Diego. But
the Thrills aren't afraid to display more modern influences: a small audience at an
Abbey Road gig was handed a one-sided 7" single with a cover of
the Smiths' classic
"Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me." Their band name is also partly inspired by
Michael Jackson's LP
Thriller, and they covered
"Billie Jean" on the English television show
RE:COVERED. The three singles stand out on first listen as being radio-friendly hits:
"Big Sur" opens with a zap of
electronic keyboards, is driven by a melancholic banjo riff, and reinterprets the lyrics from
the Monkees' theme: "Hey, hey you're
the Monkees/People said you monkeyed around, but nobody's listening now."
"Santa Cruz (You're Not That Far)" has an inventive time-shifting melody and gorgeous backing vocals, but
"One Horse Town," while being a satisfying slice of
surf pop, is too repetitive and bland.
There are moments when
the Thrills produce some lavish, well-crafted
pop songs:
"Your Love Is Like Las Vegas" is a glorious uptempo anthem that features an inspired choppy guitar solo. Unfortunately, the slower songs on the album break up the uplifting momentum of the LP:
"Hollywood Kids" and
"'Til the Tide Creeps In" just drag along and aren't as successful as the simpler, jauntier numbers like the
Dukes of Hazzard-style
country-pop of
"Say It Ain't So." With its impeccable vocal harmonies, catchy hooks, breathy laid-back vocals, and upbeat simple tunes, this is perfect
bubblegum music with a nostalgic sound that adopts the sun-seeking vibe and sound of the Golden State, but still manages to remain contemporary. As for the rest, the one-dimensional repetitive lyrics ("You said, 'Let's go to San Diego/Hey that's where all the kids go'" on
"Deckchairs and Cigarettes") do begin to irritate after a while, particularly when vocalist
Conor Deasy constantly name-checks American cities. So it comes as no surprise that the band should record its debut LP in Los Angeles.
Tony Hoffer, the producer behind
Air,
Beck, and
the Smashing Pumpkins, offers a competent helping hand but the album would have benefited from a dirtier, bluesier sound; the production is far too polished, giving the LP a somewhat sterile feel. Still,
So Much for the City is at times a beautifully rendered album with surprisingly solid songwriting; it's an unashamedly nostalgic musical postcard from the American West Coast. As a first LP, it shows signs of real promise, but it remains to be seen what direction
the Thrills will follow next. They simply can't keep on borrowing from the
Americana musical gold mine for much longer, because they couldn't sustain listener interest across the space of a second album.
~Morgane Lhote, All Music Guide
;)
Listen
