Rating:
Genre:
Rock
Release Date: 10/27/2009
While
Jade's only album is decent early-'70s
British folk-rock, its similarity to the material that
Sandy Denny sang lead on with
Fairport Convention is so evident that it's rather unnerving.
Marian Segal sounded more like
Denny than any other
British folk-rock singer of the time did, and the songs mixed
rock music, more
traditional British Isles folk melodic and lyrical elements, and stirring contemporary
rock singer/songwriting in much the same way that
Fairport did in their
What We Did on Our Holidays and
Unhalfbricking era. The differences? Well,
Jade had a little more of a
pop influence than
Fairport, occasionally using orchestration, and less of a
traditional folk one, never updating
trad folk tunes with
rock arrangements as
Fairport sometimes did. And of course where
Fairport split up the lead vocals among several members,
Marian Segal takes almost all of them here, though the good amount of vocal harmonies again can't fail but to recall early
Fairport. The title track in particular recalls
Denny's composition
"Who Knows Where the Time Goes." Ultimately, the songs, singing, and arrangements don't have as much of an edge as
Fairport Convention, and
Jade can't help but sound derivative, though they're good at what they do. The inevitable comparisons recede a bit on some songs, such as
"Mayfly," with its gallivanting, almost
country feel;
"Bad Magic," which seems
Donovan-influenced with its harpsichord and loosey-goosey
blues-rock feel;
"Away from the Family," a nod in the direction of
the Band; and
"Mrs. Adams," which more than any other track is like a modernized old
British folk song. The 2003 CD reissue adds two bonus cuts -- covers of
Joni Mitchell's
"Big Yellow Taxi" and
James Taylor's
"Carolina in My Mind" -- from an unreleased 1971 single, as well as some Chicago radio ads for some local
Jade gigs and lengthy historical liner notes by
Marianne Segal (aka
Marian Segal) herself.
~Richie Unterberger, All Music Guide
;)
Listen
