Rating:
Genre:
World
Release Date: 09/19/2006
Like some other regional
world music compilations on the
Union Square group of labels, this features both
traditional sounds of a certain territory, and far more recent, contemporary-at-time-of-issue styles that make far greater use of cutting-edge electronics. In the case of this two-CD set documenting sounds of Madrid (mostly taken from tracks recorded in the '90s and early 2000s), the first disc is entirely devoted to the kind of
flamenco music that most listeners around the world associate with Spain. The second CD is an entirely different affair altogether, as it's more concerned with fully produced
dance-oriented tracks that, while they often contain hints of more
traditional Spanish and/or
flamenco, are by no means simply updated spins on the
flamenco form. On the one hand, this kind of sequencing makes sense, ensuring a much more consistent tone on each of the approximately hour-long discs. On the other, it seems likely that many listeners who are primarily fans of
traditional flamenco will have little or no use for the second disc, and that only the more open-minded admirers of the second disc will be too enthused about the quite different stuff on disc one.
Judged on its own merit, disc one is a pretty good, diverse survey of work from about a dozen
flamenco artists, one of whom (
Ketama, represented both by one of their own tracks and a collaboration with
Toumani Diabaté and
Danny Thompson) has experienced a fair amount of international success. Although the arrangements are often oriented toward acoustic guitar and voice, it's not wholly acoustic or purist/preservationist, even if a humble melancholy does permeate much of the melody and instrumental/vocal delivery. While disc two's cuts are undeniably more ambitious in their mix-n-match combinations of sounds from different styles, they're also less likable, often bearing an in-your-face, calling-attention-to-itself cleverness. Elements of
hip-hop,
funk, and
electronic dance collide with samples,
jazz/
flamenco riffs, sound effects, repetitious distorted vocal snatches and what have you (even some Indian film music), though the accomplished editing together of the parts is more impressive than the songs per se. As for overlap with disc one's more organic approach, there's not much, though
Moraíto featuring
Navajita Platéa play straightforward
flamenco, and
Ketama show up again in a collaboration with
Toumani Diabaté and
Jose Soto -- a performance that might have fit better on the first disc than the second.
Pata Negra also use a more conventional approach to music-making on
"Blues de la Frontera," though it's more
flamenco than
blues.
~Richie Unterberger, All Music Guide
Cart 0 items
Listen
